Islanders 4, Canadiens 3 (OT): Pageau wins it after Schaefer-Dobson draw
· Yahoo Sports
Noah Dobson scored two fist-pumping goals in his first meeting against his old team, but Matthew Schaefer scored two of his own to erase those, then the Islanders tied the game late with a sixth attacker, which set the table for Canadiens-killer J-G Pageau to score the OT winner in Montreal.
Visit sweetbonanza-app.com for more information.
The 4-3 win gives the Isles a two-point boost coming out of the Olympic break, in a game that could’ve slipped away from them after an unimpressive second period (until Schaefer’s late heroics) and a power play goal gave the Habs a 3-2 lead midway through the third.
The Islanders hardly touched the puck in OT through two long but mostly unthreatening shifts, before Simon Holmstrom won a faceoff board battle with, um, Dobson, and sent Pageau off to the races to settle down a wobbly puck just in time.
[NHL Gamecenter | Game Summary | Event Summary | Natural Stat Trick]
The Isles had a decent start and though they opened scoring in the first period, but Marc Gatcomb’s goal was called back for offside, with Schaefer the glaringly guilty party. That seemed to stunt the Isles’ energy or give the Canadiens a boost, because play started to tilt after that.
Dobson’s opener at 12:11 wasn’t a particularly threatening play — though Schaefer screened Ilya Sorokin on the shot after stumbling from a netfront battle — but it followed a sequence of increasing, sustained Montreal control.
The Islanders made it to the first intermission only trailing one, but they didn’t rebound in the second. Cole Caulfield had a bid to make it 2-0 immediately waved off due to a kicking motion.
This play was called "no goal" due to a distinct kicking motion by Cole Caufield. pic.twitter.com/vGxWxkxBhh
— TSN (@TSN_Sports) February 27, 2026
Scott Mayfield took the first penalty of the game, and Dobson converted on that power play to give the Canadiens a real 2-0 lead, one that seemed imposing at the time, based on how things were going.
But, well, you know: anything Dobber can do, Schaefer can do better.
The Islanders got the break they needed with a nearly full two-minute 5-on-3. It looked like they would need every second of it before Schaefer finally broke the ice with a wicked shot through the defender’s legs and over the glove. That got the Islanders on the board, though they couldn’t do anything with the remaining half minute of 5-on-4.
MATTHEW SCHAEFER WITH TWO GOALS LESS THAN A MINUTE APART! 🤯
— NHL (@NHL) February 27, 2026
What can't this kid do? pic.twitter.com/g22x2eiara
In-game #Skinny: First 5-on-3 goal for #isles since January 2024, when they scored in Roy's return to Montreal. #NHL#NHLStats
— Eric Hornick (@ehornick) February 27, 2026
However, thankfully, Schaefer wasn’t done. Less than a minute later, he did one of his regroups, calling for the puck back at their blueline, flying through the neutral zone, orbiting behind the net, changing directions to shake the checkers and then whipping another shot through a screen to tie it at 2-2.
Most goals by an 18-year-old defenseman in NHL history.
— Isles Territory (@IslesTerritory) February 27, 2026
Matthew Schaefer is unbelievable. #Islespic.twitter.com/rsTpEWGAje
So they were back even, a new game headed into the third period. They’d just need a solid start and a better 20 minutes and…oh. Simon Holmstrom took a penalty 18 seconds in, one of two correct-but-soft tripping calls the Isles would take.
They killed off the first one convincingly. They killed most of the second one (seven minutes later) with the same approach, but a squib through the crease left an open net for Caulfield to slam it home and give the Habs the lead with 10:49 to go in the period.
Things looked stark, but for once the Islanders pulled the goalie during a proper flow into the zone. Their top guys maintained possession despite some close calls from good defensive pressure from the Habs. Just when it seemed like that would all be for naught on that shift, Bo Horvat’s last-gasp shot from the high slot deflected in off the chest of captain Anders Lee, playing his 900th regular season NHL game.
Mr. 900 is Mr. Clutch ! Anders Lee ties the game with 1:41 left. #Islespic.twitter.com/nD9B8g1FZt
— The Elmonters (@TheElmonters) February 27, 2026
We were mercifully spared a shootout thanks to Pageau finishing the game 1:46 into OT. The Canadiens won the faceoffs and controlled the puck up to that point, but they didn’t really threaten thanks to patient positioning from the Isles.
When Pageau won the next draw in the D-zone to the right wing, Holmstrom won his battle and chipped a puck off the boards to send his running mate in. The puck seemed to be wobbling all night, as if the [telecom or bank or whatever] Cent(e)r(e) ice care team took the entire Olympics off, and Pageau indeed had to settle this one before depositing it between Sam Monte…Monteba…Monte-not-gonna-work-here-much-longer’s legs.
Up NextHolmstrom beat Noah Dobson on the wall before making an incredible pass to Pageau for the game-winner 👀 pic.twitter.com/hX0IpZoVqd
— Rob Taub (@RTaub_) February 27, 2026
This mini-post-Olympic road trip continues Saturday in Columbus, the opener of a back-to-back that finishes back home against the Panthers.