After the UFC 334 headliner, we need to talk about the difference between a good fight and a fun fight

· Yahoo Sports

Was the main event title fight between Ciryl Gane and Josh Hokit at UFC 334 a sloppy mess or a good fight? Reasonable people can disagree, but maybe there's a third option to consider.

Plus, what is even the point of Jon Jones battling people like Hokit on social media now that his days of battling in the cage are (supposedly) over? All that and more in this week's mailbag. To ask a question of your own, hit up @BenFowlkesMMA on X or @Ben_Fowlkes on Threads.

Visit amunra-online.pl for more information.

@JeanLeBaptist: Goat DJ says the main event of 334 was awful. Bisping says, but it was entertaining.

Does this just prove what everybody was saying a couple of weeks ago... We are getting further from the best fights and fighters and moving more and more toward spectacle?

Two former champions

I think what it proves is that we don't all come to this sport hoping to see the exact same thing at all times — and that's fine. Some people love a wild slobber-knocker way more than a highly technical chess match. Other people geek out over Granby rolls and intricate footwork battles. There's all different ways for this thing to give people something worth seeing. Let a thousand blossoms bloom and whatnot.

I think what we're actually arguing about, especially in the case of Ciryl Gane vs. Josh Hokit, is the difference between a good fight and a fun fight. Personally, I would argue that all good fights are fun fights, but not all fun fights are good fights.

Josh Hokit and Ciryl Gane delivered plenty of action, but whether that made for a good fight or merely an entertaining mess is up for debate.Sarah Stier via Getty Images

There is a certain entertainment value to seeing two people throw strategy and proper technique out the window in favor of scrapping it out like a couple stray cats in the alley at midnight. There can be a wild recklessness to that. It can feel urgent and exciting and entertaining to watch, but we don't have to pretend it was a great display of mixed martial arts. We can just let it be fun and sloppy and maybe even a little bit stupid.

I thought Gane vs. Hokit was a very fun fight to watch. I was entertained the whole way through. It had lots of action, high stakes, big questions being answered in unexpected ways right before our eyes. I enjoyed watching it. I even enjoyed watching it a second time with the commentary off to reassess the scoring. (Gane won that fight.) But did I come away feeling like I watched a fight between the two best heavyweights in MMA, putting the very best of this sport on display? I did not, no. But that doesn't mean I didn't still have a good time, dammit.

@NoahSas23: What a wild main event. Watching it live in the arena, it felt like Hokit won but the consensus to the people watching it on tv leaned Gane. Why do you think there's such a discrepancy in between what the live audience feels vs the tv audience?

They're two totally different experiences! Watching a fight live, you're mostly limited to one vantage point. You can look up at the big screen when your view from your seat isn't great, but for the most part you end up watching things from the singular perspective you paid for.

Plus, you're bound to be influenced by the reaction of the crowd around you. If the people in your ear are erupting for every strike landed by one fighter and silent through everything the other guy does, that's inevitably going to affect your perception.

The same stuff happens when you watch it on TV. You're influenced by the commentary. You're influenced by the camera angles. A punch seems to land cleanly from one vantage point, but might have looked a lot less effective when seen from the opposite side of the cage.

I also think that our pre-fight expectations alter our perception. If we think one fighter is going to get crushed, and then he does way better than expected (but still not good enough to win), we're way more likely to interpret that surprise as success. It's a natural human reaction. It's also why judges are warned not to score "sympathy rounds," where they give a losing fighter too much credit just for improving from one round to the next.

I think every fight fan should experience a live UFC event in person at least once. But that's in part because it is such a different viewing experience. It's never quite the same as watching it on TV.

@MMAFAN2019: If it happens, just how big would a Aspinall vs Gane rematch be?

It's the biggest heavyweight fight the UFC could make without re-signing Francis Ngannou or coaxing Jon Jones out of retirement. (More on the latter in a moment.) Of the men currently on the roster in that division, Tom Aspinall vs. Ciryl Gane is the only fight that would feel like a true battle between the top two seeds.

Then you add in the revenge angle? That's huge, and rightly so.

Think about all the fake beefs and manufactured hype we sit through in MMA. How many times have we heard "it was just to sell the fight" once the fight is over? Here you have a guy whose very promising and very lucrative career is in jeopardy because of the illegal actions of the other guy. And it's not just his career — it's his vision!

If and when Aspinall is able to return, it will only be after he's spent months and possibly years confronting the possibility that Gane's fingers might have robbed him of not just his livelihood but also his ability to live a normal life. How could he not feel some type of way about that guy? And how could we not feel some type of way about seeing Aspinall get his chance at payback in the one sport where violent vengeance is not only allowed but very much rewarded?

@bodkins_nick: We have seen the back n forth with Hokit and Jones. Do you think this puts the coaches in awkward spot?

I can't even imagine what it would be like to work with either of those guys while all this is going on. I have to think that any coaches who know both men have made a deal with themselves to not pay attention and/or not get involved in this part of it.

The part I don't understand right now is, what's in this for Jon Jones? He says he's retired. He says he has no interest in coming back to fight in the UFC. So why get into this increasingly ugly and uncomfortable online beef? It makes some sense for Hokit. He's an active fighter who benefits from having his name in the headlines alongside one of the all-time greats.

But for Jones it does nothing of value. It's just attention for attention's sake, much of it extremely negative. But then, maybe for some people the attention itself is all the reward they need.

@pmsdeadandalive: is the ufc quietly getting rid of women's divisions entirely? seems like every non title fight is loser leaves town at this point. tbh maybe mvpfl is the better home of women's mma, especially the way the ufc desired fight outcome and chauvinistic fan base have both (d)evolved.

There definitely seems to be a shift in UFC policy, but I'm not sure it's limited to the women's divisions. It's possible that it's just even more pronounced and noticeable there, since there are a lot fewer female fighters on the roster.

The situation with Virna Jandiroba is interesting, though. She just fought for a UFC title last year and lost — but not by much. Then she had a rebound fight that she won, followed by a fight against current top-ranked contender Tatiana Suarez, which she lost. Those were the only two losses she had in the past five years with the UFC. If that's all it takes to get cut in the middle of a contract, that's a big change for the way this sport works.

At the same time, we kind of get it, don't we? Jandiroba is 38 and does not have much of a fan base. She got a shot at a UFC title and then a shot at a top contender who might have propelled her to another title shot. She lost both those, which would seem to indicate some sort of ceiling at her age and level of professional development. I think we can understand how the UFC might have looked at Jandiroba and thought, what else can we really do with her?

What makes it tricky is that she probably still beats a lot of ranked strawweights in the UFC. She is, in that sense, one of the best in the world at that division. So does cutting her mean we're not interested in having the best fight the best?

I think maybe it means that, especially in divisions where the UFC feels like there's less return on investment, the worst place to be in the rankings is standing still. If you're actively moving up, you have a future. If you're steadily falling, you're still useful as a stepping stone for younger fighters climbing the ladder. But if you're hanging out at three or four, beating all those below and losing to all those above, you might be chopping block material.

@DTBolton1234: If you had to pick a 90's WWF wrestler to take over and run the UFC who would it be and why?

The one who would fit in the best with current TKO executive leadership is obviously "The Million Dollar Man" Ted Dibiase. It's so easy to picture him delivering a Q3 earnings report to shareholders while assuring them that everyone has a price.

As for who I'd personally want to see come in and make some changes? I have to go with Dusty Rhodes. He knows hard times, daddy.

@khansen406: Who you got in the Brawl of the Wild?

Please. When it comes to the greatest college football rivalry in America — University of Montana Grizzlies vs. Montana State Bobcats — you know I'm a Griz fan all the way. I won't say I don't have some concerns about Saturday's game, especially with the way the Griz defense has made every opposing quarterback look like a star.

But with Eli Gilman putting up video game numbers at running back and Brooks Davis having a career year at wide receiver, this might be the best Griz offense I've ever seen. I predict they'll have to score at least 50 points to win this game, but way down in my brain's heart I believe they can do it.

Read full story at source